User:Myask/Myapper thoughts

8x8 attributes, beginning of 8x1

User:Myask/MyaGrafx

8x1 attributes?

It's all in the fine Y and keeping it in mind. The intensive solution is to watch the PPU bus and keep our own copy of PPUSCROLL, which requires knowing the latch and thus watching several of the registers. Pattern-fetch snooping can yield it, but as it is after the attribute fetch, it does not work for the first fetch of a scanline. Triple fetch is after said 2 pre-fetched tiles. Is really a double-fetch duplicating next one normally, but VBLANK is between the last line's double-fetch and the first of pre-render, which is interrupted by whatever the program wants to access. One could count tiles, then:

if(this_fetch == last_fetch) reset(counter);
if(is_AT(this_fetch) && is_NT(last_fetch)) counter += 1;
if(counter == (32? 33? 34?)) //override the usual pattern, we're doing first prefetch
///...after which we can just let the pattern fetch give us the information

But is this any simpler than register-snooping? This segues nicely into a scanline counter interrupt, though for some reason I have the thought of a nametable-relative Y-based interrupt instead (which is just a different frame of reference on the same thing.) Resetting to "scanline 0" if no triple-fetch detected in 128 CPU clocks seems workable.

Flipping

BG tileflipping is pretty easy.

chr_a[2:0] = ppu_a[2:0] ^ {3{is_chr_access & vert_flip}};
ppu_d[7:0] = (is_chr_access) ? (horiz_flip ? chr_d[0:7] : chr_d[7:0]) : something_else);

If one stored the attributes in the same byte you can piggyback that to set the flip bits. But what to use the other four bits for? Just do two tiles per byte? Allow MMC5-like extended tile index allowance? Allow swapping of two colors in the attribute?

wire invert_cur = ppu_a[4] ? invert_plane1 : invert_plane0;
ppu_d[7:0] = (is_chr_access) ? (invert_cur ^ (horiz_flip ? chr_d[0:7] : chr_d[7:0])) : something_else);

Rotation would require orthogonal accesses, all-but requiring in-chip CHR. Note: one should only do this if things are following (AT,NT,PT,PT) pattern. If not, one is fetching sprite patterns. While it is of mild interest that there are 64 sprites filling out the 32x32 count, OAM already deals with that better.

Though, one could use the garbage NT fetches (which are a double fetch, can leech off logic detecting the triple fetch!) to add extended per-sprite banking, though detecting which sprite is which is Another Problem, requiring either duplicating/spying OAM's tile entry, or requiring some specific pattern of sprite arrangement (useful for static images?). This also allows some odd bits, like changing sprite tile mid-sprite (vertically).

DMA theft

If you watch for a $4014 write, you can then watch the DMA happen...and thus have another destination to copy it to. This could alleviate the VBLANK crunch a bit (for e.g. the 8x1 mapper), as DMA copies much faster than program can. Obviously bringing it into the chip 'à la' MMC5 means one could allow access to both buses, but that costs a lot of chip resources.

Slideshow mirroring

PPUDOUT[0:7] = PPUDIN[0:7] & {8,{~PPUA[11]&PPUA[9]}};//causes all tiles to be 0 and also be BG color
CIRAMA10 = PPUA[10];
//ab
//00

Of course, the slideshow effect could be done without any special hardware just by using a render-disable raster effect instead of a scroll.

Fill Mode

…is an expansion of the above:

wire is_fill_mode = (nt_mapping[PPU_A[11:10]] == FILL_MODE) && is_nt_fetch;
PPUDOUT[0:7] = is_fill_mode ? fill_chr[0:7] : chrdin[0:7];

Actually, now I think it, "CIRAM0, CIRAM1, disable, fill mode" isn't a bad set of 4. Catch is, of course, that that would mean cartside NT0-3 makes it 12 bits of mirroring to allow full control, two writes. That leaves four bits of unused write…

Textbox Bank

Sort of an expanded MMC4, switch NT(+AT) as well as CHR bank on detecting certain tile-reads.

Note that this means you don't have to align the textbox to a 16x16 as the switch will also switch on per-tile where the palette comes from.

This lets you arbitrarily block-group off tile blocks of the screen for certain segments (see: Fire Emblem textboxes). However, you might need to use sprites to mark the corners; otherwise you need extra viable start- and end-tile designations in the mapper, eating up your usable tilespace.

It need not be for a textbox, a portrait or some sub-part of the screen that tends to be CHR-greedy. For instance, consider the Macventure ports (Shadowgate et al.) and their boxing-off of the screen: one could expand the Current Scene viewpoint to a full 16x16 tiles with just one bank. (It's presently 14x14, and looking at the Sphinx image showed that the two most common tiles were 61 of the 196 tiles available,) Of course, this has the drawback of reducing the overdraw fraction of such a viewport available to increase colordepth from sprite palettes.

Oekarcade

One need not bank the CHR on vertical quarters of the screen like Oeka Kids. One could arbitrarily section the screen, like so:

Example 1					Example 2					Example 3
1	1	1	1		1	2	3	1		1	1	2	2
2	4	4	2		3	4	4	2		1	1	2	2
2	4	4	2		2	4	4	3		3	3	4	4
3	3	3	3		1	3	2	1		3	3	4	4

Remember, any quartering of the screen is sufficient to allow every tile to have its own bitmap.